I don’t see why there is a debate about whether or not story has a place in videogames. I think it’s very clear that most, if not all, people are compelled by narrative in games or otherwise. We have clear examples in film and literature, two fields dedicated solely to the craft of narrative (experimental film and literature aside, for now), but we can still find less obvious examples that show us how much more involved we become when a set of events becomes story.
Good games deserve a good narrative. Granted, a game doesn’t need a narrative to survive, or even be fun, but leaving it out is akin to, say, using nothing but stock art from the 8-bit-era. In both cases, things are going on onscreen, but none of it makes very much sense. Tetris’ art is about equivalent to its story.
But every game, even the simplest of designs, can benefit from story, if it is intelligently conceived. Jeff Ross, of Sony bend, has a quote on Joystiq:
“Since game mechanics can only reproduce the abstraction an experience, it is left to story/theme/narrative to help complete player immersion. Consider Frequency and Amplitude, two fun and very abstract music games that most people have never heard of. Simply changing the theme and adding a guitar-shaped controller transformed the experience completely. People were no longer pressing random buttons in sequence to music, they were rock stars. This is narrative at work.”[Joystiq 2008/12/22]
Maybe Tetris could have been even more with this kind of creative thought. The key is to have narrative that can amplify the gameplay, much like good art in a game. It seems though that all too often developers don’t consider this balance when creating their product. They choose to mimic the motions of a ‘riveting story’ so that they can use the claim as a bullet point on the back of their box. They don’t consider whether their story is serving their gameplay or vice versa. When developers recognize how to find this balance, their game succeeds. It is, however, often too difficult a question to answer whether a game concept calls for more or less narrative. The ‘narrative’ given in the example above, transforming Amplitude into Guitar Hero, is really more of a change of framing than an added narrative, but it is a valid narrative design choice nonetheless. It’s clear how that small shift can affect sales, at least.
Tom Gaubatz, producer for publisher Mastiff, says of story in games that:
“It depends completely on the genre and the title. That said, a huge part of our concept of games is still inherited from early arcade games: stimulate the player just enough to make him put in another quarter. Games are still, in most cases, very much about short-term rewards. Regardless of the quality of the story, if the gameplay doesn't deliver regular challenges and psychological rewards, people won't play it.”[Joystiq, 2008/12/22]
But what about games that have a balance that favors narrative over gameplay? Look at the Ace Attorney series. It is difficult to argue that they are more game than novel, but they are popular among a hardcore gaming crowd nonetheless. Capcom has attempted, and largely succeeded, in delivering those same challenges and psychological thrills that would normally come from gameplay through their storytelling. The player must be smart enough and, more importantly in this case, absolutely engaged in the minutia of the story to complete the game. Knowing the story is being good at the game.
A large part of the resistance to story in games seems to be simple misunderstanding. Have a look at the following quote by Ben Mattes, producer of the newest Prince of Persia:
“As I mentioned earlier, I think we could have done a better job in giving more challenge to those gamers who play a game to Accomplish and Achieve, rather then Experience. We talked a lot about it during development (multiple difficulty settings, etc) but could not come up with a way to modify all aspects of the game (combat, acrobatics, trap difficulty) in a graceful and interesting way.”[IGN, Prince of Persia Afterthoughts]
Mattes, here, is making the mistaken assumption that players that want to Achieve and those who want to Experience are mutually exclusive. He is also asserting that games cannot offer both at once. By attempting to separate the desires of what may very well be the same buyer, one who wants to both Experience and Achieve in their gaming, the team created a product that did little in the way of grabbing peoples’ attention (beautiful art style aside).
It seems that many developers are pre-disposed against including story in their games, if only for the simple reason that it is difficult:
“Telling stories in games is hard. Consider that a game is an 8-24 hour experience. When did you see an interesting and compelling 8-24 hour movie last? Games have to find their own way of telling stories, instead of relying on old methods from other mediums. The problem is that movies are so standard it's a hard thing to change.”[Ulf Andersson, GRIN co-founder and Bionic Commando game director, Joystiq 2008/12/23]
Why is
It is surprising that more developers haven’t started looking for other methods of telling their stories. Good ideas for pacing and tension wouldn’t be hard to find. Maybe they could turn on their televisions and realize that shows like Lost, Dexter, House, any television drama, really, have perfected, to an art, the idea of drawing out a story. Granted, Lost might have alienated a lot of its viewership with a convoluted plot, but it had the idea of small, focused stories inside a larger narrative absolutely right, which is something more games, especially ones that are seeking to be called story-based, should look to include. How many life stories can you find, should you choose, on the computers in Fallout 3? Enough for a few hours of good reading, certainly, and it all gets counted towards “gameplay length” because the disc is still spinning in your console. Tricky.
Regardless of how developers choose to justify their aversion to story, they can’t avoid that people look for it in nearly all aspects of their lives. Sports fans follow their favorite teams, and players, and usually know the ups and downs of any given career. That investment adds to the excitement. You can see peoples’ personal investment in soap operas, in professional wrestling, racing, reality television—in almost all aspects of life, recreational or otherwise. If there’s a plot, natural or conceived, there’s a reason to follow it.
Excellent article. I'd like to add a couple of examples to stimulate the discussion here:
ReplyDeleteCarrion Re-animating
A very simple indie game that uses dynamic narration and simple arcade game mechanics to breath life into a story from Lovecraft's Commonplace Book.
Passage
Arguably the most emotive game ever made, Passage is a memento mori that takes only 5 minutes to play.
Both of the above examples provide fascinating story experiences while working around constraints that all but eliminate the Hollywood experience. If developers want to learn how to add stories to their games, they should start here with the basics.
On a tangent, I'd like to note how MMORPG games all seem to desperately want to include a story in their games, but fail miserably with each attempt. Adding a story to a persistent world is a challenge on its own that no developer should take lightly.
Well played, I agree whole heartedly. Ace attorney is a prime example of amazing storytelling, god knows there's been so many times where I've tried to convince someone to play it. This is because on one hand the gameplay itself is very simplistic, and on the other hand difficult to describe the storyline without making it sound boring, strange or even spoiling it. It's a game/storyline where one has to experience it firsthand to enjoy.
ReplyDeleteAnother one is Metal Gear; I still remember the conversations we've had sitting down playing through MGS3:Snakeeater and absolutely loving it, except for it's controls which didn't feel natural or sometimes even clunky. For me personally what breaks or makes a game is two things: Camera and Control Scheme, but in the case of metal gear I had to adapt to the controls to continue Snake's adventures in wild wild Russia.
Passage was really amazing. Thanks for the contribution, Kev.
ReplyDelete